my reading journal

my reading journal

Sunday, April 15, 2012

"Up in The Air"

Upon watching the movie “Up in the Air” it is easy to see that it is vastly different from the book it was scripted after. Director Jason Reitman changed a dry, aimless work of literature into a film with direction and purpose. In the book version of “Up in the Air”, Ryan Bingham is largely alone. He is isolated from his family, lacks any real friends and makes his home in various hotels and airport lounges. Ryan of the book seems to be content with his way of life and does not seem to want for any human attachments, his greatest aspirations involve the prospect of a new job with a company called “Mythtech”, reaching one million frequent flyer miles, and publishing a business novel. Although, Ryan Bingham of the movie also makes his home in “Airworld” he seems to encompass more real human emotions. Throughout the movie, you get the idea that an ocean of feelings is lurking just beneath the cold, calculated surface of the Ryan that is depicted onscreen. Also, the movie version does not leave Ryan Bingham as isolated as the novel. Ryan is almost always accompanied by Alex, his reluctant love interest, or Natalie, an intelligent young woman who was designated to shadow Bingham in order to learn the ways of his company. Overall, the movie far exceeds the book in its ability to give Ryan human emotions and therefore making him a more dynamic character. The movie version makes you actually care about Ryan and therefore, makes you care about the movies messages of hope, and need for human connection. Here is an interesting link that contains information on the effects of social isolation.

4 comments:

  1. Tracy,
    I also admired Reitman’s transformation of a dry, aimless novel into an enjoyable film with direction and purpose. The absence of MythTech and The Garage in the film may be beneficial to analyze in your essay. There were a few important differences that you skillfully picked up on. The Ryan Bingham in the film is much more connected with human emotion and this makes a statement about the contextual changes in business. This goes hand-in-hand with the need for human connection and is demonstrated through Bingham’s rejection to use skype for CTC. In addition, his lack of isolation is quite significant. It was not completely clear which statement was your thesis. You might want to make it stand out more and wrap up your thoughts with a more powerful statement. You have some great ideas and the potential for a superb essay. Great job.
    -Aaron

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like your post, the book and the movie are different I think why they made it didn't is to please the viewers of the movie to get more money.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that the movie was impressive in terms of how it made him easier to sympathize with. I also feel you found many great examples of how this was done. I would suggest, however, going over your paragraph because I thought it was difficult to find your thesis statement.
    Phill

    ReplyDelete
  4. I found your post to be a very well written summary. The comparing and contrasting you did was adept, but basic. I think overall you need to have a stronger thesis that I could argue with. You seem like a very strong writer and I look forward to reading the rest of your paper.

    ReplyDelete